Selecting Siblings to Help Sick Kids

摘要： ‘Selecting‘ Siblings to Help Sick Kids Center Combines Fertility Technique, Tissue Typing to Choose Children With Lifesaving Stem Cells BySalynnBoyles WebMD Medical News Reviewed ByMichaelSmith,MD on Tuesday, May 04, 2004 ......

• 临床快报
• 药市动态
• 违法广告
• 医保动态
• 药品价格
• 流感疫情
• 保健常识
• 妇科课堂
• 医改动态

Designer Kids?

While there are legitimate "Brave New World" concerns surrounding new technologies that allow parents to select the traits of their children, bioethicists contacted by WebMD say they have few concerns about using preimplantation genetic diagnosis to avoid life-threatening genetic illnesses and possibly save sick family members.

In an editorial accompanying the study, Norman C. Fost, MD, addressed the criticism that as preimplantation genetic diagnosis becomes more refined, people may use it to select trivial traits like eye color. This "slippery slope" argument, he notes, can be made with just about all new technology, "since new technology almost always has undesirable consequences." Fost directs the program in medical ethics at the University of Wisconsin and is the former chairman of the American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Bioethics.

Ethicist Josephine Johnston says that given the expense and poor success rate of IVF, it is unlikely that couples will choose it over natural conception for frivolous reasons. Johnston is an associate for ethics law at the Hastings Center for bioethics research in New York's Hudson River Valley.

"With the trauma and uncertainty involved with IVF, people certainly aren't clamoring to do it if they can conceive naturally," she says. "But the concern about designer children may become more real if the success rate for IVF improves."

'The Best Outcome'

Lisa Nash says she and her husband heard all the criticisms but consider preimplantation genetic diagnosis a godsend that gave the Colorado couple the option of having a desperately wanted second child that could, as an added bonus, help make their first child well.

It took them five IVF attempts, at a cost of more than $80,000, to have Adam and two other attempts to have a third child 13 months ago.

"My worst fear was that I would have other kids who would only know Molly through pictures, or that my husband and I would have never had any other children because of the risk of passing this illness on," she says. "Out of the possible scenarios, this technology gave us the best outcome imaginable."

SOURCES: Verlinsky, Y. The Journal of the American Medical Association, May 5, 2004; vol 291: pp 2079-2085. Anver Kuliev, MD, PhD, Reproductive Genetics Institute, Chicago. Josephine Johnston, associate for ethics law in society, Hastings Center for bioethics research, Garrison, N.Y. Norman Fost, MD, professor and vice chairman of pediatrics; director, Program in Medical Ethics, University of Wisconsin School of Medicine.

发布日期：2006-6-27

• 关键字：
• Selecting
• Siblings
• Help
• Sick

输入您的搜索字词 提交搜索表单
互联网 本站 企业频道